Possible blog post:
Can Beer Be Truly Organic?
Beer is a popular drink worldwide, appreciated for its taste, variety, and social role. However, beer is also a complex product, with many ingredients and processes involved in its production, ranging from water, grains, hops, yeast, and adjuncts to milling, mashing, boiling, fermentation, conditioning, and packaging. Therefore, the question of whether beer can be truly organic is not a simple one, but a multifaceted issue that requires considering various aspects of organic agriculture and brewing. In this blog post, we will explore the debate over natural ingredients, the challenges of brewing without chemicals, and the potential for organic beer to meet consumer demand for sustainable and healthier beverages.
The Debate Over Natural Ingredients
The first question to ask when talking about organic beer is what makes an ingredient or product organic. According to the USDA National Organic Program (NOP), organic agriculture is a system “that integrates cultural, biological, and mechanical practices that foster cycling of resources, promotes ecological balance, and conserves biodiversity.” This means that organic farming aims to minimize the use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides, protect soil and water quality, and enhance natural processes that support plant growth and health. Organic agriculture also involves animal welfare standards, such as providing access to outdoor pasture and avoiding antibiotics and hormones.
Applying these principles to beer brewing, we can say that organic beer should use organic ingredients that have been grown and processed according to organic standards. This includes sourcing organic grains, such as barley, wheat, or rice, and organic hops, a plant that provides the bitterness and aroma to beer. Organic yeast, a microorganism that converts sugar into alcohol and carbon dioxide, may also be used, although it is harder to certify as organic due to its natural origin and variations. Additionally, organic brewing may exclude adjuncts, such as corn or rice syrups, that are commonly added to beer to enhance its flavor, texture, or alcohol content, but may come from non-organic sources.
The debate over natural ingredients in beer goes beyond the organic label, as many brewers and consumers advocate for using local, seasonal, or experimental ingredients that may not fit into strict organic or conventional categories. For example, a microbrewery in Portland, Oregon, called Upright Brewing, specializes in using wild yeast strains from local orchards, instead of commercial yeasts, to create sour and funky beers that reflect the terroir and culture of the region. Similarly, a craft brewery in Santa Fe, New Mexico, called Rowley Farmhouse Ales, experiments with using herbs, fruits, and spices from the nearby hills and gardens to add flavor and complexity to their beers. While these approaches may not be certified as organic, they represent a small-scale, artisanal, and creative way of brewing that values diversity, innovation, and locality.
Is It Possible To Brew Without Chemicals?
Another aspect of the organic beer debate is the challenge of brewing without chemicals. Most conventional beers use various additives, processing aids, and preservatives that may improve shelf life, clarity, or foam stability, but may also have negative effects on taste, health, or ecotoxicity. Some examples of these chemicals are:
– Sugars and dextrins: used as adjuncts to increase the alcohol content or body of beer, but may lead to residual sweetness or stickiness.
– Enzymes: used to break down starches or proteins in the brewing process, but may affect the flavor or aroma of beer if not controlled.
– Oxidants: used to remove unwanted flavors or aromas from beer, but may also alter the natural compounds and nutrients that contribute to beer quality.
– Antimicrobials: used to prevent bacterial or fungal contamination during brewing or storage, but may also kill beneficial microorganisms that contribute to flavor or health.
In contrast, organic brewing aims to minimize or exclude such chemicals, and rely on natural processes and ingredients to achieve the desired taste and quality. For example, some organic brewers use decoction mashing, a traditional technique that involves boiling a portion of the malted grains to release more flavor and color compounds, and then mixing it with the rest of the grains to create a complex mash profile. This method can enrich the beer with melanoidins, caramel-like compounds that contribute to the maltiness and aroma of beer, without requiring additional adjuncts or additives.
Organic brewing also involves careful selection of hops, as this ingredient can be a major source of synthetic pesticides and fertilizers. Certified organic hops must be grown without synthetic pesticides, herbicides, or fertilizers, and be harvested by hand or mechanically without leaving residues or damaging the plant. However, organic hops may not be as consistent or abundant as their conventional counterparts, and may require more attention and skill from the brewer to achieve the desired bitterness, aroma, or flavor. Some organic brewers also experiment with using alternative bittering agents, such as herbs, spices, or fruits, that can add unique flavors and aromas to beer while reducing the reliance on hops.
Despite these challenges, many brewers have successfully embraced organic brewing, and achieved recognition and awards for their natural and flavorful beers. For example, Alaskan Brewing Company, based in Juneau, Alaska, has been brewing organic beer since 1998, and has won medals at international competitions for its organic amber ale, porter, and wheat. The company uses a unique steam-powered brewing system that reduces its carbon footprint and energy consumption, and sources its organic ingredients from regional farmers and suppliers.
The Potential For Organic Beer To Meet Consumer Demand
As the awareness and demand for organic and sustainable products grow worldwide, the potential for organic beer to meet consumer expectations and preferences also increases. According to a survey conducted by the Organic Trade Association in 2020, the organic beer market in the US has grown steadily over the past decade, with sales reaching $151 million in 2019, up from $57 million in 2010. The survey also found that organic beer drinkers are more likely to value environmental and health benefits, as well as unique and local flavors, than conventional beer drinkers.
Moreover, organic beer may offer some health benefits that are not available in conventional beer. For example, organic beer may contain higher amounts of antioxidants, B-vitamins, and amino acids, as well as lower levels of synthetic chemicals, that can contribute to better cardiovascular, neurological, and immune health. However, these benefits depend on the quality and quantity of the organic ingredients, as well as the brewing process and storage conditions, and may not apply to all organic beers equally.
In conclusion, the debate over whether beer can be truly organic reflects a wider discussion on the goals and challenges of organic agriculture and brewing, as well as the expectations and preferences of consumers. While brewing without chemicals and sourcing organic ingredients can be difficult and costly, organic beer offers a way to promote sustainability, health, and diversity in the beer industry, and to connect with local communities and ecosystems. Whether you prefer organic or conventional beer, it is important to be aware of the choices and values that shape the beer you drink, and to support brewers who are committed to transparency, innovation, and quality. Cheers!
Image Credit: Pexels